Do what you want with the guys on your roster. If you had Mick Foley for example, i dont think anyone would find it odd if you made him into Mankind or something. The characters storyline, gimmick, heel/face alignment and all the rest are up to you.
And ya Finlay's ok. I was thinking the rosters are looking a little thin at the moment. I would also like to add Goldberg... just a fav from my childhood.
The Internet
Where Men are Men
Women are Men
And Children are FBI Agents